An apartment building's hot water load does not change when the fuel does. What changes is where the equipment sits, who hears it, whose closet it takes and which electrical panel carries it.
Electrifying with in-unit heat pump water heaters puts one machine, one circuit, one condensate drain and one compressor in every apartment. Electrifying with a central plant puts one heat pump bank, one storage bank and one recirculation loop in a mechanical room and nothing in the units. Owners, developers and engineers choose between the two on space, electrical capacity, resident experience, maintenance access and building height. The thread that runs through the central case is storage: it lets one plant serve the morning peak without a heat pump sized for that peak.
Key Takeaways
- In-unit HPWH requirements per the DOE distributed HPWH guide: room volume of 450 cubic feet or more, such as a 7 by 8 foot room with an 8 foot ceiling, or ventilation; both intake and exhaust ducted outdoors if ducted at all; a dedicated 240 V 30 A circuit for standard models, with 240 V 15 A and 120 V 15 A lower-power models for retrofits; condensate to a floor drain, utility sink or washer drain, with heat tape where it could freeze; water-resistant flooring and a floor drain for leaks.
- In-unit sizing per the same guide: first hour ratings of 30, 40 and 42 gallons for 1-bed/1-bath, 2-bed/1-bath and 2-bed/1.5-bath units; 40, 50, 64 and 80 gallon HPWHs rated 58, 66, 78 and 92 gallons first hour; 65 and 80 gallon units typically serve two or three apartments in a cluster. Clusters of two to four units reduce space and cost but a single failure affects several homes.
- Resident experience is a constraint. The distributed guide calls out noise and cool, dry exhaust in small dwellings. The NLR preprint reports that noise was the main resident complaint in a Florida deployment of more than 1,000 integrated HPWHs, and that integrated units are typically 60 inches or taller where many apartments had 30-inch lowboys.
- Central plants per the DOE central HPWH guide: three to four times the efficiency of gas or electric resistance; storage used to meet peaks with heat pumps running 16 to 20 hours per day; single-pass units using stratified vertical storage; multi-pass units raising tank temperature 5 to 10 F per pass; and a 115 to 125 F recirculation loop supported by a swing tank with primary storage at 150 F or greater, a dedicated maintenance tank or a return-to-primary arrangement.
- Field performance from the ETCC multifamily central HPWH field study: five California central plants in buildings of 8 to 50 units measured average system COP of 1.9 to 3.2 and delivered 99.8 percent of draw volume at or above 110 F. Electric resistance backup barely ran, but its standby losses lowered efficiency.
- Split in-unit systems with the compressor outdoors remove noise and cold exhaust from the apartment, operate to −25 F and produce about 145 F water through a 125 F mixing valve. NLR reports that split CO2 units cost about twice as much as integrated units, while sharing one outdoor unit across two tanks cuts cost per apartment by about one third.
- 60-unit example: 606 million Btu per year, 177,600 kWh thermal, and 487 kWh thermal per day. A central plant at COP 2.5 uses 195 kWh electrical per day. A morning peak equal to a third of the day is 162 kWh thermal and fits two 700-gallon modules at the rated delta before the usable delta is applied.
The DOE Building America Solution Center distributed HPWH guide says an in-unit heat pump water heater needs a room of at least 450 cubic feet or ventilation, a dedicated 240 V 30 A circuit in standard models, a condensate drain, placement away from bedrooms, and indoor installation wherever outdoor temperatures regularly fall below 50 F. It is best suited to buildings of seven or fewer floors.
The DOE central HPWH guide says a central plant is three to four times as efficient as gas or resistance heating, uses large storage to meet peaks with heat pumps running 16 to 20 hours per day, carries a recirculation loop held at 115 to 125 F whose losses need their own solution, and needs structural and seismic review for its tanks. In a 60-unit worked example based on the EIA average of 10.1 million Btu per household, the building needs about 487 kWh thermal per day. In-unit heaters put 60 circuits of 7.2 kW nameplate into 60 closets, while a central plant at COP 2.5 draws about 195 kWh electrical per day and carries a morning peak of roughly 162 kWh thermal in two 700-gallon modules.
In this article
- The load is the same; the question is where it lands
- What an in-unit heat pump water heater asks of each apartment
- What a central plant asks of the building
- A 60-unit worked example, with the assumptions labeled
- How to choose
- Frequently Asked Questions
- The bottom line
The load is the same; the question is where it lands
The EIA's 2020 Residential Energy Consumption Survey puts water heating for apartments in buildings with five or more units at 10.1 million Btu per household per year, 29.9 percent of 33.7 million Btu of total site energy. That is about 2,960 kWh thermal per apartment per year, or 8.1 kWh thermal per day, before any plant efficiency.
An in-unit design meets the load 60 times in 60 places. A central design meets it once, plus the loop losses that an in-unit design does not have. Everything else in the decision follows from that split.
What an in-unit heat pump water heater asks of each apartment
The DOE Building America Solution Center's distributed HPWH guide sets out conditions on the apartment, not on the mechanical room.
- Space and air. In rooms under 450 cubic feet, the guide says HPWHs are likely to operate much less efficiently. Its example is a 7 by 8 foot room with an 8 foot ceiling. Smaller closets need passive or active ventilation. If the unit is ducted, both intake and exhaust must go outdoors because mixing interior and exterior air creates a pressure difference that increases air leakage. Tight floor plans can leave no room for the tank plus a duct elbow.
- Height. The NLR preprint notes that integrated HPWHs are typically 60 inches or taller, while many multifamily units were built with lowboy water heaters about 30 inches tall. Nearly 85 percent of multifamily in-unit tanks are under 50 gallons.
- Electrical. Standard models need a dedicated 240 V 30 A circuit. Lower-power models run on 240 V 15 A or 120 V 15 A, which helps in retrofits where the unit panel has no spare capacity. Sixty apartments means 60 circuits and, in many older buildings, 60 panel upgrades.
- Condensate. The drain goes to a floor drain, utility sink or clothes washer drain, or to landscaping where it will not freeze or create a slip hazard. Heat tape may be needed. The guide recommends water-resistant flooring and a floor drain in case of a leak.
- Noise and comfort. The guide recommends placing units away from bedrooms and living areas or insulating the walls. It flags cool, dry exhaust as a comfort issue in small dwellings. The Florida deployment of more than 1,000 integrated units in the NLR preprint produced noise as the main resident complaint.
- Climate. Outdoor air is acceptable in IECC zones 1 and 2. Indoor air performs better in zones 3 and 4, where exterior closets need active ventilation and efficiency drops in the coldest months. Interior air is recommended elsewhere. In retrofits, install indoors if outdoor temperatures regularly fall below 50 F.
- Sizing. First hour rating is the sizing metric: 30, 40 and 42 gallons for 1-bed/1-bath, 2-bed/1-bath and 2-bed/1.5-bath units. These are met by 40, 50, 64 and 80 gallon HPWHs rated at 58, 66, 78 and 92 gallons first hour. Raising the setpoint adds capacity but needs a thermostatic mixing valve, reduces efficiency and can shorten tank life. The guide prefers a larger tank.
- Circulation. The guide advises avoiding circulation loops with distributed systems. Where one is needed, it recommends an occupant-activated pump rather than a timer or continuous circulation.
Split in-unit systems
The split configuration places the compressor outdoors and the tank inside. It removes noise and cold exhaust from the apartment. NLR's lab work on a split CO2 unit found that it held delivered water at the 125 F target through a 93-gallon high-draw test, produced about 145 F water through a mixing valve and operated at outdoor temperatures down to −25 F.
The trade is cost: about twice an integrated unit. Sharing one outdoor unit across two tanks cuts cost per apartment by about a third, with a manufacturer estimate of up to four tanks per outdoor unit.
What a central plant asks of the building
The DOE central HPWH guide describes a system in which all equipment sits outside dwelling units. This simplifies maintenance and frees in-unit space. The guide calls central systems appropriate in every U.S. climate zone with the right equipment. The conditions are on the building.
- Two loads, not one. The primary load heats cold city water to delivery temperature. The temperature-maintenance load replaces heat lost from the recirculation loop, which is typically held at 115 to 125 F. Heat pumps handle the first load well and often struggle with the tepid return of the second. The loop therefore needs its own arrangement: a dedicated maintenance tank with a multi-pass heat pump, a swing tank in series with primary storage held at 150 F or greater, or a return-to-primary design with a multi-pass unit. The recirculation article and swing tank article cover the choice.
- Storage, not capacity. Storage is far cheaper than heat pump capacity. Central plants carry large storage and run heat pumps up to 16 to 20 hours per day to recharge it. Oversized heat pumps raise project cost unnecessarily. Single-pass units need stratified vertical storage. Multi-pass units, heating 5 to 10 F per pass, work with horizontal tanks.
- Climate. Frost forms on evaporators at roughly 20 to 45 F. Defrost reduces capacity and efficiency. CO2 units operate far below 0 F. Designers check capacity and COP at record low, design cold and design hot temperatures. A below-grade garage can temper intake air. The cold-climate article covers the storage consequence.
- Space and structure. Central systems take more area than a central gas plant because of larger equipment and more storage. Tanks are heavy and need structural and seismic review. Outdoor heat pumps are larger and louder than in-unit machines and may need sound compliance at the property line.
- Condensate and controls. Indoor condensate goes through an air gap to a floor sink. Outdoor condensate must not pool on walkways and needs heat trace in freezing conditions. The guide requires pre-startup checklists, functional testing and alarm reporting. This is a controls contractor's job, not a plumber's.
- Retrofit path. A common retrofit adds a primary heat pump as a preheater and converts the existing plant to in-series temperature maintenance. Existing water heaters can serve as swing tanks after inspection.
Field performance
The ETCC study of five California multifamily buildings of 8 to 50 units, across four recirculation configurations, measured average system COP of 1.9 to 3.2. It found that 99.8 percent of draw volume was delivered at or above 110 F, with owners reporting no ongoing operational issues.
The authors note that the installers were experienced and that the results are likely best-case retrofits. Electric resistance backup barely ran, but its standby losses lowered efficiency. The central HPWH article covers equipment selection and sizing.
A 60-unit worked example, with the assumptions labeled
The following calculation uses labeled assumptions: 60 apartments; the EIA RECS 2020 figure of 10.1 million Btu per household per year for water heating in buildings of five or more units; a central plant COP of 2.5; a morning peak equal to a third of the day; and the TEHQ 700-gallon module at 108 kWh thermal at a 35 C (63 F) delta.
- Load. 60 apartments × 10.1 million Btu = 606 million Btu per year, 177,600 kWh thermal, and 487 kWh thermal per day on the EIA average. The building's own meter replaces this assumption.
- In-unit. 60 heat pump water heaters, 60 closets of at least 450 cubic feet or 60 ventilation arrangements, 60 condensate drains, and 60 dedicated 240 V 30 A circuits at 7.2 kW nameplate each. This is 432 kW of circuit capacity across the unit panels. The 7.2 kW figure is nameplate capacity, not measured demand; the heat pump itself draws far less than the circuit rating. Each unit meets its own 8.1 kWh thermal per day with no loop loss.
- Central at an assumed COP of 2.5. This is inside the 1.9 to 3.2 measured range: 487 kWh thermal per day ÷ 2.5 = 195 kWh electrical per day, or about 71,000 kWh electrical per year, before loop losses. The design adds and measures those losses.
- Central storage. A morning peak of a third of the day, assumed, is 162 kWh thermal. The TEHQ 700-gallon module stores 108 kWh thermal at a 35 C (63 F) delta. Two modules therefore cover the peak at the rated delta before the usable delta is applied. Each module is 60 inches in diameter and 88.6 inches tall, weighs 6,046 lb filled, carries 308 lb per square foot, occupies about 20 square feet of footprint and loses 2.4 F per 24 hours. The sizing calculator sets the count from the building's own draw profile and the usable fraction. The specification sheet provides the module data.
- Central electrical. One plant sized to the daily load with storage draws roughly half the kW of one sized to the peak. The NEC 220.87 article gives the measured-demand method for checking the existing service.
How to choose
The architecture should follow the building's physical constraints and operating requirements. No dollar-cost conclusion follows from the source data; the sources provide cost ratios only for the split-system comparisons.
- Building height and staff. Seven floors or fewer without maintenance staff points toward in-unit, per the DOE distributed guide. Taller buildings and staffed properties point central.
- Closet reality. Measure the existing water heater closets. A 30-inch lowboy space and a 60-inch integrated unit do not meet. A split system or a corridor cluster may be the only in-unit route.
- Panel reality. Count spare 240 V 30 A circuits. Where there are none, lower-power in-unit models or a central plant on the house meter are the options.
- Loop. A building with an existing recirculation loop already pays its losses. A central plant with a swing tank keeps them, while an in-unit design removes them. This is the strongest technical argument for in-unit in a building that can accept the closets.
- Climate. Zones 5 and above push in-unit heaters indoors and push central plants toward CO2 equipment and more storage.
- Resident experience. Noise and cold exhaust are the recorded complaints. Central plants have neither inside the apartment.
- Replacement cycle. In-unit heaters are replaced one apartment at a time for the life of the building. The DOE residential water heater standard is covered in its own article. A central plant is replaced once.
- Peak. The central plant's case rests on storage covering the morning. Size it from the draw profile before pricing the heat pumps. The hub article on electrifying hot water in existing buildings gives the full sequence.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which is better for an apartment building, central or in-unit heat pump water heaters?
Neither is better in general. The DOE guides suit in-unit systems to buildings of seven or fewer floors without maintenance staff and central systems to larger, taller and staffed buildings. Closets, panel capacity, the existing loop and climate decide the rest.
How much space does an in-unit heat pump water heater need?
The DOE distributed guide says rooms under 450 cubic feet, such as a 7 by 8 foot closet with an 8 foot ceiling, likely reduce efficiency much and need ventilation. Integrated units are typically 60 inches or taller.
What electrical circuit does an in-unit heat pump water heater need?
A dedicated 240 V 30 A circuit is specified for standard models. 240 V 15 A and 120 V 15 A lower-power models exist for retrofits.
Are heat pump water heaters noisy in apartments?
Noise was the main resident complaint in a Florida deployment of more than 1,000 integrated units reported in the NLR preprint. The DOE guide recommends placement away from bedrooms or insulated walls, and split systems move the compressor outdoors.
What COP does a central heat pump water heater plant achieve?
Five California multifamily plants measured average system COP of 1.9 to 3.2 and delivered 99.8 percent of draw volume at or above 110 F, according to the ETCC field study.
How much hot water energy does an apartment use?
The EIA's 2020 survey puts water heating at 10.1 million Btu per household per year in buildings of five or more units, or about 2,960 kWh thermal per year and 8.1 kWh thermal per day.
Why does a central plant need so much storage?
Storage is far cheaper than heat pump capacity. The DOE central guide describes plants that meet peaks from storage and run heat pumps 16 to 20 hours per day to recharge it. This keeps the heat pump bank and its electrical service small.
Can an existing central gas plant be converted?
The DOE central guide describes a common retrofit that adds a heat pump as a preheater and converts the existing water heaters to in-series temperature maintenance after inspection.
The bottom line
The hot water load is fixed; the architecture decides where it is paid for. In-unit heat pump water heaters pay in closets, circuits, drains and resident patience, 60 times in a 60-unit building, and avoid the loop.
A central plant pays once in the mechanical room, keeps the loop and depends on storage to cover the morning with a heat pump bank that fits the service. On the EIA average, a 60-unit building needs about 487 kWh thermal per day, and two 700-gallon modules carry the peak at the rated delta.
Measure the closets, count the circuits, meter the loop and let those three numbers make the choice before any equipment is specified.


