A campus converts its steam system to hot water because the heat sources that replace gas boilers make hot water. Heat recovery chillers, ground-source and air-source heat pumps, wastewater heat recovery, and enhanced geothermal deliver water at 120 to 180 F; they do not deliver steam at 450 F.
The conversion enables the replacement plant and reduces distribution losses. Cornell reports roughly 20 percent steam distribution loss and projects about 5 percent for hot water. Princeton is moving buildings from 450 F steam and 180 F hot water to a 140 F loop, while Stanford reports that heat recovery chillers meet 88 percent of campus heating.
At each building, domestic hot water that previously came from a steam heat exchanger must be produced from the new loop or a local heat pump. Storage carries the morning peak so the building heat exchanger or heat pump can be sized near the average load.
The published sequence is to cut heating demand, cut peaks, convert the distribution from steam to low-temperature hot water, and then electrify the plant. Steam distribution losses, condensate return problems, and century-old pipe drive the cost side of the conversion.
Cornell reports steam distribution costs of about $1 million per year against a projected $270,000 for hot water. Replacement plants combine heat recovery chillers, ground-source and air-source heat pumps, geothermal sources, and storage. Stanford holds 2.3 million gallons of hot water and 4.3 million gallons per chilled water tank.
Capital is substantial. Massachusetts' public campus studies estimate $30 to $350 per square foot across four campuses, and UC Davis reported $55.2 million for its first 31 buildings. At the building, a 140 F loop can make 120 F domestic hot water through a heat exchanger if storage carries the morning peak.
In this article
- Why steam goes first
- The loop temperature decision
- What the replacement plant looks like
- Capital cost and project time
- The building-level problem the loop leaves behind
- Worked example: a 300-bed dormitory
- Hospitals and the same arithmetic
- A conversion sequence for the building owner
- Frequently Asked Questions
- The bottom line
Why steam goes first
Steam is a 450 F medium carried in pipe that, on an old campus, can be a century old. Cornell's account describes parts more than 100 years old and pipe from the 1920s. About 80 percent of the underground network has been upgraded, including about 12 miles of steam main and 10.5 miles of condensate return.
Cornell reports roughly 20 percent energy loss in steam distribution. The hot water conversion is projected to reduce that to about 5 percent and reduce distribution cost from about $1 million per year to $270,000. The reported reduction is 73 percent.
UC Davis made a similar case for its Quad District conversion. Abandoning the aging steam pipelines was expected to save more than 25 percent in additional energy on top of the plant change, and the full conversion could reduce campus carbon emissions by up to 40 percent.
The replacement heat sources make hot water. Cornell's Earth Source Heat project, an enhanced geothermal demonstration, generates hot water and therefore requires a hot water distribution system. Princeton's TIGER plant is fed by heat pumps, and Stanford's heat comes from heat recovery chillers.
Washington State's guidance places the work in four steps: reduce heating demand, reduce or eliminate peaks, convert steam to hot water, and then electrify. It also instructs designers to incorporate thermal storage into the loop for load management.
The loop temperature decision
Princeton's reported numbers frame the choice. Its buildings previously received steam at 450 F and hot water at 180 F; the new loop supplies 140 F. Cornell's building heat exchangers deliver 120 to 180 F from steam today.
A 140 F loop is the temperature identified in the brief for heat pumps and heat recovery chillers to operate at a usable COP, the ratio of thermal output to electrical input, while producing 120 F domestic hot water through a heat exchanger with a few degrees of approach. Above about 180 F, the plant options narrow to boilers and the highest-temperature industrial heat pumps; below 140 F, domestic hot water needs a booster.
The building side pays for the lower temperature. Washington's guidance identifies low-temperature terminal units, low-temperature building heating systems, and loop connections designed for hot water. Heating coils sized for 180 F water deliver less at 140 F, so some are replaced, some buildings receive more flow, and envelope work reduces the required load.
The campus loop as a system is its own subject. This article stays with what happens at the building wall.
What the replacement plant looks like
The published campus plants share a pattern built around heat recovery, heat pumps, and storage.
- Heat recovery chillers carry the base. Stanford's reported machines are 2,500 tons each with 41 million Btu per hour of simultaneous heat output. By recovering heat from the chilled water loop, they meet 88 percent of campus heating and have cut water use by over 70 percent. The heat recovery chiller article covers when this arrangement works and when storage is needed alongside it.
- Ground-source heat pumps and bore fields carry seasonal storage. Massachusetts' studies use ground-source heat pumps as the base system for all four campuses, with heat recovery chillers for simultaneous loads and air-source heat pumps as an intermediate supplement or for buildings off the loop. Princeton's geo-exchange bore fields store summer heat in the ground for winter.
- Other sources remain under study. Massachusetts lists wastewater heat recovery pending feasibility. Cornell is pursuing enhanced geothermal. The DOE Better Buildings Carleton College case study documents a steam-to-hot-water transition with a geothermal project; no figures from that case study are used here.
- Storage decouples the plant from the hour. Stanford holds 2.3 million gallons of hot water and 4.3 million gallons per chilled water tank, totaling 90,000 ton-hours. Massachusetts' summary lists cold and warm water storage tanks as a supplement to geothermal wells. Princeton's plan adds more thermal storage.
Capital cost and project time
The capital range is wide. Massachusetts' public campus studies, conducted across four campuses from January 2020 to August 2021, provide construction-only estimates of $30 to $350 per square foot for the overall program. Building upgrades range from $4.50 to $160 per square foot, and energy supply ranges from $15 to $100 per square foot.
The Massachusetts studies use ground-source heat pumps as the base, heat recovery chillers for simultaneous loads, and air-source heat pumps as a supplement. Wastewater heat recovery and cold and warm water storage tanks were under consideration. Reported campus targets range from 100 percent renewable heating and cooling by 2032 at UMass Amherst to carbon neutrality by 2050 at UMass Lowell.
UC Davis's first district included 31 buildings, 2.8 million square feet, and four miles of supply and return pipe. The reported cost was $55.2 million in 2020.
Cornell reports that its conversion is about 20 percent complete against a 2035 campus-wide target. Princeton expects about 20 years to reach every building and reports a net-zero-without-offsets target by 2046.
A campus planning this work is planning a decade or two of phased construction. The sequence therefore starts with demand and peaks.
The building-level problem the loop leaves behind
On a steam campus, domestic hot water commonly comes from a steam-to-water heat exchanger, often an instantaneous exchanger. Steam at 450 F through a tube bundle can make 140 F water as showers draw it. The source was, for practical purposes, unlimited at the building.
A 140 F hot water loop is not unlimited. It was sized for the campus average load with diversity, its heat exchangers have a finite approach, and a dormitory's morning shower peak is a coincident load that the loop designer must either oversize for or buffer.
There are two building-level designs.
- Loop-fed with storage. A loop-to-domestic heat exchanger sized near the building's average hot water load charges storage, and the storage carries the morning peak. The heat exchanger, loop branch, and plant share of the peak shrink. A 140 F loop against a 140 F storage setpoint requires the approach to be designed in, which usually means a loop supply a few degrees above the storage setpoint or a storage setpoint a few degrees below the loop. The 140 F storage article covers the Legionella side of that choice.
- Local heat pump with storage. Buildings off the loop or ahead of its arrival can use a heat pump water heating plant sized to the daily load and charge storage overnight. The cold-climate article covers derate, and the central heat pump water heater article covers plant design.
- Either design uses storage in the building. It can occupy the basement where the steam heat exchanger and condensate receiver were. The TEHQ 700-gallon module stores 108 kWh thermal at a 35 C (63 F) delta, is 60 inches in diameter and 88.6 inches tall, weighs 6,046 lb filled at 308 lb per square foot, loses 2.4 F per 24 hours under free convection, is rated to 200 F working fluid, and assembles from panels that pass through the door. The existing buildings article covers placement and floor loading. The reported heat-loss specification is also provided in the TEHQ specification sheet.
Worked example: a 300-bed dormitory
The following calculation uses labeled assumptions: 300 beds at 20 gallons per bed per day of hot water, 6,000 gallons per day; water heated from 58 F to 140 F, an 82 F rise; one third of the day's draw in a three-hour morning window; and 8.34 pounds per gallon.
All kWh values below are kWh thermal.
- Daily heat: 6,000 × 8.34 × 82 = 4,103,000 Btu, 4.10 MMBtu per day, about 1,203 kWh thermal per day.
- Average rate over 24 hours: 4.10 / 24 = 0.171 MMBtu per hour, or 171 kBtu per hour.
- Morning window: one third of the day is 1.37 MMBtu. Delivered in three hours, that is 455 kBtu per hour.
- Heat exchanger without storage: sized at 455 kBtu per hour or more, with the loop branch and plant carrying the same peak.
- Heat exchanger with storage: sized near the 171 kBtu per hour average, 62 percent smaller. Storage carries the difference.
- Storage to carry the window: 1.37 MMBtu is about 401 kWh thermal. At 108 kWh thermal per module at the rated 35 C delta, four modules are required before the usable delta is applied. The sizing method article and calculator set the count from the building's own draw profile and usable delta at the selected setpoints.
- If the building is off the loop: a heat pump plant at the 171 kBtu per hour average, or 50 kW thermal, with the same storage, compared with 455 kBtu per hour, or 133 kW thermal, without storage.
Hospitals and the same arithmetic
A hospital campus has the same steam system, with sterilization and humidification loads that can keep some steam in service after heating moves to hot water. The hospital central plant article covers tank location and regulated-market cautions.
The domestic hot water conversion follows the same two designs: a loop-fed heat exchanger with storage or a local heat pump plant with storage. The storage-temperature decision has the same Legionella constraint.
A conversion sequence for the building owner
The building owner should follow the campus sequence and coordinate each building's domestic hot water conversion with the loop schedule.
- Follow the campus sequence: demand reduction and envelope first, then peak reduction, then the loop, then the plant.
- Inventory every steam-to-domestic heat exchanger and its peak draw. Load profiles for the kitchen, pool, laundry, gym, and schools and universities set the relevant peaks.
- For each building, choose loop-fed with storage or local heat pump with storage based on the loop schedule. Buildings reached last receive the heat pump plant first.
- Size storage to the morning window and the heat exchanger or heat pump to the daily average. Confirm floor loading and door access for the basement.
- Set the storage setpoint against the loop supply temperature and the Legionella program together.
- Re-verify every campus figure before reuse. The figures are reported plans and results, and several are projections that the universities may update.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why are campuses converting steam to hot water?
Because the replacement heat sources—heat recovery chillers, ground-source and air-source heat pumps, and geothermal—make hot water rather than steam. Steam distribution also loses more energy and costs more to maintain. Cornell reports roughly 20 percent steam distribution loss against a projected 5 percent for hot water and distribution cost of about $1 million per year against a projected $270,000.
What temperature is a campus hot water loop?
Princeton's new loop supplies 140 F, replacing steam at 450 F and hot water at 180 F. Cornell's building heat exchangers deliver 120 to 180 F today. Lower loop temperatures can improve heat pump COP, but building terminal units and domestic hot water design must support the selected temperature.
How long does a steam-to-hot-water conversion take?
Cornell is about 20 percent complete with a 2035 target. Princeton expects about 20 years to reach every building. UC Davis's first 31-building district was a multiyear project begun in 2020. Conversions are phased by district.
What does it cost?
Massachusetts' public campus studies estimated $30 to $350 per square foot for the overall program, construction only, with $4.50 to $160 per square foot for building upgrades and $15 to $100 per square foot for energy supply. UC Davis's Quad District, with 31 buildings and 2.8 million square feet, was reported at $55.2 million.
What replaces the boilers?
Replacement plants can use heat recovery chillers that make hot and chilled water at once, ground-source heat pumps with bore fields that store summer heat, air-source heat pumps as a supplement, and large thermal storage. Stanford reports that its heat recovery chillers meet 88 percent of campus heating and that it holds 2.3 million gallons of hot water.
How is domestic hot water made after the steam is gone?
It is made through a loop-to-domestic heat exchanger charging storage or through a local heat pump plant charging storage. In the 300-bed dormitory example, storage sized to the morning window lets the heat exchanger be sized at 171 kBtu per hour instead of 455 kBtu per hour.
Where does thermal storage go in a campus conversion?
Storage goes at the plant, as in Stanford's 2.3 million gallon hot water tank, and at each building where domestic hot water peaks are buffered so the loop and plant see average load. Washington State's guidance tells campus designers to incorporate storage for load management on the loop.
Does a 140 F loop make domestic hot water hot enough?
It can deliver 120 F through a heat exchanger with a few degrees of approach. Storage at or near 140 F requires the loop to be a few degrees above the storage setpoint or the storage setpoint to be a few degrees below the loop. The 140 F storage article covers the Legionella and mixing-valve side of that choice.
The bottom line
A steam-to-hot-water conversion enables the rest of a campus decarbonization program and can reduce distribution losses on its own. The reported figures are roughly 20 percent steam distribution loss to a projected 5 percent for hot water, about $1 million per year in distribution cost to a projected $270,000, and 450 F steam replaced by a 140 F loop.
The replacement plant can include heat recovery chillers, ground-source heat pumps, air-source heat pumps, enhanced geothermal, and millions of gallons of storage. At the building, the steam heat exchanger that produced domestic hot water on demand is replaced by a heat exchanger or heat pump sized to average load, with storage sized to the morning peak.
Size the storage from the building's draw profile, place it where the existing mechanical equipment permits, and coordinate the storage setpoint with the loop temperature and Legionella program. Re-verify every campus figure on publish day because several values are projections and reported plans.


